Skip to content

The University of Iowa Libraries

Skip to content
Go to
InfoHawk+
University of Iowa Libraries University of Iowa Libraries The University of Iowa The University of Iowa Libraries

Library News

Go to the University of Iowa Libraries home page
University Libraries - IOWA
Oct 13 2021

Evidence Synthesis Institute

Posted on October 13, 2021October 13, 2021 by Carolyn Simon

By Kelly Hangauer

In August 2021, I had the opportunity to participate in the Evidence Synthesis Institute. This four-day online institute is funded by the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) and is a partnership between University of Minnesota, Cornell University, and Carnegie Mellon University. The goal of the institute is to equip librarians who work outside of the health sciences with the tools to provide evidence synthesis support at their institutions.

So what is evidence synthesis? Evidence synthesis (ES) is a broad term that encompasses all types of reviews including systematic reviews, meta-analyses, scoping reviews, critical reviews, rapid reviews, mapping reviews, umbrella reviews, etc. The most common reviews, and the ones we focused on the most, are systematic reviews.

Evidence synthesis is an increasingly important aspect of academic research and informs evidence-based practices. While ES is most common in the health sciences, it is also important for social sciences. In my work as a liaison to the College of Education and Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, I have noticed a demand for this type of service among faculty and graduate students.

The Evidence Synthesis Institute was thoughtfully arranged. Not only did we have presentations, breakout rooms, and small group debriefs, but we also had clear objectives and informative videos available through PressBooks. The coordinators of the Institute are all librarian experts with lots of ES experience.

Librarians are perfect partners for ES work and can raise the caliber of an ES project. This is because ES necessitates complex search strategies using Boolean operators, keywords, and Subject Terms; thorough knowledge of databases and indexes; strategies for finding grey literature; and citation management. Librarians can collaborate in a consultation or co-authorship capacity, depending on the level of involvement.

Prior to attending the Institute, I received excellent training from Jen DeBerg at Hardin Library and had built up some experience consulting and co-authoring on ES publications. The Institute reinforced what I had already learned and gave me a greater appreciation for reporting guidelines (such as PRISMA and PRESS), protocol registration, frameworks for extracting concepts (such as PICO, SPICE, and SPIDER), and ensuring the entire search strategy is transparent and reproducible. In fact, one of the biggest takeaways from the Institute is that transparency and reproducibility are extremely important and can best be accomplished by engaging in peer review of search strategies and publishing complete search strategies through institutional repositories or the Open Science Framework.

I am thankful for having had the opportunity to participate in this Institute and would highly recommend it to other librarians who are interested in becoming more involved in ES work.

Posted in Main Library, News

Post navigation

Seeking nominations for the Benton Award
Tadoku Hour: reading in Japanese for fun!

Categories

  • Anti-racism
  • Art Library
  • Business
  • Collection Connection
  • Cultural Center Liasions
  • Did You Know
  • Digital Scholarship & Publishing Studio
  • DVD Display
  • Employment
  • Engineering
  • Event
  • Faculty News
  • Hardin
  • History
  • ICBF
  • ICBF2010
  • Iowa Digital Library
  • IWA
  • Learning Commons
  • Main Library
  • Music
  • New Books
  • News
  • Preservation
  • Research Data
  • Scholarly Communication
  • Scholarly Impact
  • Sciences
  • Special Collections
  • Transitions
  • Uncategorized
  • University Librarian
  • What's new

Archives

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Stories about the Libraries published in the University of Iowa's Iowa Now

Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Zoia by Automattic.
University of Iowa Libraries University of Iowa Libraries The University of Iowa The University of Iowa Libraries
  • Contact the Libraries
  • Library locations & hours
  • News & Events
  • Help using the Libraries
  • Assistance for people with disabilities
  • Our diversity statement
  • Thank a Librarian
  • Web site/page feedback OR general suggestions
  • UI Libraries other links UI Libraries in the Internet Archive Use and reuse of UI Libraries web content - Creative Commons Staff SharePoint (authentication required)
  • UI Libraries on social media UI Libraries on Instagram UI Libraries on Facebook UI Libraries on Twitter UI Libraries on Pinterest UI Libraries on Tumblr UI Libraries on YouTube UI Libraries on Flickr UI Libraries blogs
  • 100 Main Library (LIB)
  • 125 West Washington St.
  • Iowa City, IA 52242-1420
  • 319-335-5299 (Service Desk)
  • ©2019 The University of Iowa
  • Give a gift to the Libraries!